Thursday, 11 December 2014

First Draft Feedback


Positives
  • Editing was good. The live performance lighting effects was good. 
  • Excellent editing and use of mise-en-scene
  • Outstanding 
  • One of the best, amazing editing. 
  • Editing was amazing, so was the lighting. 
  • Really strong editing. 
  • I love the video, best one I've seen. The shots match the beat of the music, amazing editing. 
  • Pacing of the shots ties in well with the visuals. Editing is the best of the year. 
  • Amazing editing and shot selection, lip syncing is solid and great performance shots. Hard to find any complaints.

Negatives 
  • Repeated shots, could improve party shots. 
  • Maybe add an epilepsy warning. 
  • Cross media consistency isn't entirely synchronized. 
  • Grace is portrayed on her website and digipack as a girly girl and associated with pink and glitter which isn't portrayed in the video. Some shots are repeated, unsure if this was intended. 
  • Some of the same shots used twice, lose focus on the drugs and alcohol. 
  • A few repeated shots. 
  • Too much of a skins influence, not a big problem though. 
  • Just a question, why the drugs?
  • Skins scene doesn't match the stars image. Too Ellie Goulding. Flashing is not good, couldn't watch more than 30 seconds due to seizures. Trying too hard to be grunge. 
  • What's the message? Got drugs and alcohol written all over it. 
  • Want to see less of the drugs/woods scenes more. 
  • Some of the shots could be better quality (outside). Maybe less drugs and get rid of repeated shots. 
  • Repeated shots. 
  • Didn't understand what was happening outside of the performance. 
Marks given. 
 38/40
33/40
34/40
26/40
23/40
39/40
38/40
38/40
33/49
36/40
26/40
35/40
37/40
30/40

No comments:

Post a Comment